Where to Get Thanksgiving Pies Chicago

Prime & Provisions Pies

Prime & Provisions

Pies available for local pick-up only at Prime & Provisions. Shipping and delivery not available. 48 hour notice is required.

Pie Flavors:

  • Apple Cinnamon $30.00
  • Caramel Pecan $34.00
  • Traditional Pumpkin $30.00

Order: Online
222 N LaSalle St

Floriole Pie

Pick up Nov. 27th 9am-5pm.

Pie Flavors:

  • Apple Pie $30.00
  • Pecan Pie Cake $40.00
  • Pumpkin Cranberry Coffee Cake $30.00
  • Pumpkin Pie with Honey Marshmallow $30.00

Order: Online or Phone
1220 W Webster Ave

Mindy's HotChocolate Pecan Pie


Mindy’s HotChocolate @ Revival Food Hall

Place your final order by November 20th.

All Thanksgiving pre-orders must be picked up at Revival Food Hall on Tuesday, November 26 and Wednesday, November 27 from the HotChocolate Bakery at Revival Food Hall register between 8am – 6:30pm.

Pie Flavors:

  • Butterscotch Pumpkin Chiffon $30.00
  • Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie $30.00
  • Cranberry Orange Buttermilk Pie $30.00
  • Caramel Apple & Brown Butter Crumble $30.00
  • Add On: Maple Cream $6.00

Order: Online
125 S Clark St

Sweet Mandy B's Pies

Sweet Mandy B’s

We encourage you to order as early as possible. Some items will become unavailable as Thanksgiving approaches.

Pie Flavors:

  • Apple Streusel $24.00
  • Apple-Cherry Streusel $26.00
  • Pumpkin *$26.00
  • Pecan $28.00
  • Chocolate Cream $24.00
  • Banana Cream $24.00
  • Key Lime $26.00

*​no whipped cream during week of Thanksgiving

Order: Phone
1208 W Webster Ave

Bang Bang Apple Pie

Bang Bang Pie & Biscuits

All online orders are non-refundable. Your product selections, pick-up date, and pick-up location cannot be altered. Online Pre-orders are only available for pick-up on Tuesday, November 26 & Wednesday November 27. If you want pie prior to these two days, just call one of our shops!

Pie Flavors:

  • Roasted Pumpkin Pie $28.00
  • Classic Apple Pie $32.00
  • Chocolate Pecan Pie $28.00
  • Key Lime Pie $28.00
  • Chocolate Caramel $28.00

Order: Online or Phone
Logan Square: 2051 N California Ave
Ravenswood: 4947 N Damen Ave

Bittersweet Pumpkin Chiffon


Order by Monday then 25th for pickup Tuesday the 26th, or Wednesday the 27th.

Pie Flavors:

  • Classic Pumpkin Pie $20.00
  • Classic Pecan Pie $30.00
  • Chocolate Chess Pie $22.00
  • Apple Cranberry Streusel Pie $26.00
  • Door County Sour Cherry Pie $28.00
  • Double-Crust Apple Pie $26.00
  • Pumpkin Chiffon Pie $26.00

Order: Online or Phone
1114 W Belmont Ave

Hoosier Mama Pie Company Pies

Hoosier Mama Pie Company

Orders placed for Thanksgiving day will need to be picked up by 12 O’clock Noon.

Pie Flavors:

  • Apple Pie $30.00
  • Pear Apple Cranberry with Walnut Crumble $32.00
  • Maple Pecan Pie $32.00
  • Chocolate Chess Pie $29.00
  • Cranberry Chess Pie $28.00
  • Pumpkin Pie $30.00
  • Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie $26.00

Order: Online or Phone
1618 W Chicago Ave

Please follow and like us:


Chicago born and raised. Always looking for new places.

TC has 252 posts and counting. See all posts by TC

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *